The earnest money contract is the step that reserves the property before the deed, and it's also the one that raises the most questions: what happens if the buyer backs out, what happens if the seller does, and what type of earnest money is best to sign. Here are the answers to all three questions.

What is an earnest money contract

It is a preliminary agreement to the sale in which buyer and seller commit to formalizing the transaction on a specific date, with the buyer delivering a sum of money—usually 10% of the price—as a deposit. It is the most commonly used instrument in Spain to reserve a property while preparing documentation, mortgage, or deed.

Confirmatory earnest money: the default commitment

If the contract does not expressly specify what type of earnest money is agreed upon, the law understands it to be confirmatory. This type of earnest money confirms both parties' commitment to proceed with the sale, but does not allow either party to withdraw freely: if one party defaults, the other can demand performance of the contract or compensation for damages caused, through legal proceedings.

Penitential earnest money: the option to back out, with penalty

Regulated in article 1454 of the Civil Code, penitential earnest money does allow either party to withdraw from the contract freely, assuming an economic penalty agreed upon in advance: if the buyer withdraws, they lose the amount delivered; if the seller withdraws, they must return double what they received. Case law requires that this penitential nature be specified expressly in the contract; if nothing is said, it is presumed to be confirmatory.

Why the type of earnest money you sign matters so much

The practical difference is enormous: with confirmatory earnest money, if the seller receives a better offer after signing, they cannot simply return double and leave—they would be liable for breach of contract. With penitential earnest money, they can do so, assuming the penalty. Before signing, you must carefully read what type of earnest money is being agreed upon and assess what level of protection you need in each case.

What an earnest money contract should always include

  • The type of earnest money agreed upon (confirmatory or penitential), expressly stated.
  • The total sale price and the amount delivered as a deposit.
  • The maximum deadline to formalize the public deed.
  • Complete identification of the property, with its registry data.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

How much money is usually delivered in an earnest money contract?

It is customary in the Spanish market to be around 10% of the sale price, although the amount is negotiable between the parties.

Can I recover the deposit if the bank denies my mortgage?

It depends on what is agreed in the contract: it is advisable to include a suspensive condition clause linked to mortgage approval, which allows you to recover the deposit if financing is ultimately not approved.